Eat Like a Local at the Best Seafood Restaurants in Fort Myers

When you come to Florida, seafood is probably one of the first things to come to mind. After all, one of the best parts of traveling is experiencing the local cuisine, and seafood is abundant here in the Sunshine State! Our Fort Myers vacation rentals put you just moments away from the very same waters where local restaurants get their fish.

For a “taste” of the good life, check out one of these incredible seafood restaurants in Fort Myers during your stay! 

Izzy’s Fish and Oyster

If you ask a local where to find the best seafood in Fort Myers, don’t be surprised if they mention Izzy’s Fish and Oyster. Here, they use local ingredients and fish to create mouthwatering meals with a New England twist. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming with a hint of upscale class, ideal for any group to come and enjoy a delicious meal. 

Izzy’s has one of the most carefully crafted menus among Fort Myers Beach restaurants. Get started with oysters Rockefeller, Cajun shrimp hush puppies, or gator bites. You can then move on to fish or shrimp street tacos, beer-battered fish n’ chips, fried scallops, seared tuna, a lobster roll (hot or cold), and more. You can even build your own fish dish! 

Izzy’s Fish and Oyster is located at 2282 1st Street. 

A lobster roll with a cup of sauce.
Photo from Shutterstock

Three Fishermen Seafood Restaurant

For a fun dining experience for the whole family, check out Three Fishermen. This restaurant is just minutes from our Fort Myers Beach vacation rentals and offers a family-friendly atmosphere for guests of all ages. Experience unique seafood dishes with a breathtaking view of the water right beside your table! 

You’ll find unique appetizers on the menu like buffalo grouper fingers, fried gator tail, and lobster bisque. You can then move on to nearly any seafood dish you can think of, from coconut shrimp and grouper fillet to oysters, snow crab legs, and Atlantic salmon. Don’t forget to pair your meal with a refreshing beer or cocktail and finish with a slice of Key lime pie!

Three Fishermen Seafood Restaurant is located at 13021 North Cleveland Avenue. 

Plan Your Stay

Contact Kathy Nesbit Vacations today to learn more about our Fort Myers Beach condo rentals and all of our other stunning properties!

Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls

Even though Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls opened its doors in 2014, founder Dan Beck has loved and worked with lobster for more than 20 years now. Beck’s efforts crafting the perfect lobster roll now come to fruition in this welcoming establishment that’s quickly become one of the most beloved Fort Myers restaurants.  

Of course, the main attraction here is the lobster rolls themselves. You can go for the Classic, which is served chilled with mayo and lemon butter. Other popular options include the Connecticut Roll, the Lobster Salad Roll, the Lobster BLT Roll, and the Bar Harbor. If you’re not in the mood for a lobster roll, don’t worry! Go for a crab roll, lobster mac and cheese, or New England clam chowder. 

Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls is located at 2122 1st Street. 

Where to Stay

Book a stay with Kathy Nesbit Vacations to access these eateries and all the best restaurants in Fort Myers. We’re proud to offer plenty of Fort Myers Beach house rentals that are perfect for groups of all sizes. Travel with your sweetheart, or bring the entire extended family along for the adventure! For cozier and conveniently located accommodations, choose one of our Fort Myers condo rentals